
WHOSE PEACE? WHOSE SECURITY? WHOSE SOVEREIGNTY?
A People(s)-Centered Human Rights Critique of the China-Russia-U.S. Declaration toward Peace
November 19, 2026, | Shenzhen
An international order for states, but what about peoples?
The November 19 declaration issued by the heads of state of China, Russia and the United States following their trilateral summit in Shenzhen should be understood as more than a diplomatic statement about international peace and security. It raises fundamental questions about the kind of international order the world’s most powerful governments intend to construct and, more importantly for oppressed nations and peoples, whose interests that order is designed to protect.
The short declaration is striking not only for what it says, but for what it ignores. While the three governments express their commitment to international peace and security, they make no explicit reference to the promotion and protection of human rights, the self-determination of peoples, or the strengthening of international mechanisms for accountability for grave violations of international law.
This omission is no minor oversight. It reflects a troubling view of international governance in which the security, stability and prerogatives of states outrank the rights, dignity, collective aspirations and interests of peoples. What does it imply when the declaration dismisses international accountability mechanisms as needing to be reined in?
“The three heads of state recognized that the principle of state consent and respect for immunities of State officials are of paramount importance, and concurred that the International Criminal Court and other similar bodies must not abuse their jurisdiction.”
There did not appear to be any concerns about the International Criminal Court (ICC) when the court was primarily focused on prosecuting heads of states and other actors in Africa and the non-European world. Where was sovereign immunity for Nicolás Maduro, Venezuela’s head of state, when Venezuela was subjected to an extraterritorial military assault by the U.S. under the guise of a police action?
Where was the “abuse” by the ICC? Certainly, it was not reflected in the limited indictment of Israeli officials for obvious crimes against humanity and war crimes while providing impunity for U.S. officials who aided and abetted the crimes in Gaza and are clearly in breach of the Genocide convention’s article three that condemns complicity with genocide.
Perhaps this confusion or departure from international morality and law explains the abstention by Russia and China on November 17, 2025, when the UN Security Council essentially abandoned the Palestinians and all of the principles of the UN Charter when the Security Council turned over the fate of Palestinians in Gaza to the U.S. and Israel under the bizarre nomenclature of a “Board of Peace.”
For the North-South Project for People(s)-Centered Human Rights (PCHR), this declaration must be assessed against the historical and contemporary realities of imperialism, colonial domination, and the persistent subordination of peoples to the strategic interests of powerful states.
A world order for powerful states, not peoples
The first point of the declaration commits China, Russia, and the United States, as permanent members of the UN Security Council, to reforming the United Nations so that it can more effectively fulfill its fundamental mission of maintaining international peace and security.
But where are human rights in this vision? Where is the commitment to the equal rights and self-determination of peoples? Where is the recognition that the United Nations was established not simply to manage relations among states, but also to protect human dignity and advance the rights and fundamental freedoms of all?
The UN Charter explicitly identifies the promotion of human rights and the self-determination of peoples among the purposes of the Organization. Yet the three governments have chosen to emphasize peace and security while remaining silent about these equally fundamental commitments.
This is especially disturbing in a world marked by the destruction of Gaza, the continued denial of Palestinian self-determination, the military intervention against Venezuela and the capture of its president by the United States, and the intensification of economic coercion against Cuba.
These are not peripheral issues. They concern the fundamental rights of peoples to live free from foreign domination, military aggression, dispossession, and collective punishment.
The declaration’s silence on human rights, considered alongside its explicit emphasis on state immunity and constraints on international judicial institutions, raises serious questions about whether the three governments envision an international order in which powerful states negotiate their mutual security while the rights of peoples remain subordinate to their geopolitical calculations.
The principle must be clear: sovereignty without accountability becomes a mechanism of impunity. The PCHR alternative: Peoples, not power, must be at the center.
The North-South Project rejects the false choice between state sovereignty and human rights, between international peace and justice, and between national self-determination and international accountability.
We insist that human beings and peoples are not simply subjects of state authority, objects of geopolitical negotiations or instruments of national economic and security strategies. They are the ultimate subjects, determiners, and beneficiaries of human rights.
A People(s)-Centered Human Rights framework demands a fundamental reorientation of international governance.
It requires that international peace and security be measured by their consequences for the lives, dignity, and collective well-being of peoples, rather than exclusively by the strategic interests of states.
It requires recognition that sovereignty must encompass the right of peoples to determine their political, economic, social, and cultural futures, free from foreign intervention, domination, and dispossession.
It requires the protection and strengthening of international accountability mechanisms, ensuring that no government or political leader can claim immunity from responsibility for the gravest international crimes.
It requires the decolonization of international institutions and the transformation of global governance structures that continue to privilege powerful states while marginalizing the voices, rights, and aspirations of the peoples of the Global South.
And it requires an understanding of human rights that goes beyond the narrow confines of liberal individualism to embrace collective rights, economic and social justice, the right to development, environmental protection, people’s sovereignty, and human liberation.
The People(s)-Centered Human Rights Declaration: No peace without peoples, no sovereignty without accountability
The North-South Project for People(s)-Centered Human Rights rejects an international order in which the world’s most powerful governments negotiate the terms of their mutual security and immunity while the rights of humanity are relegated to the margins.
We reject the notion that a multipolar world, simply because it challenges the dominance of one geopolitical power, necessarily represents progress toward a more just and democratic international system.
We reject the use of state sovereignty to protect impunity, the subordination of people’s rights to geopolitical interests, and the weakening of international institutions established to hold perpetrators of grave international crimes accountable.
We call for the strengthening and democratization of international mechanisms of justice and accountability, and for an end to the selective application of international law.
We call for an international order in which the resources, political futures and collective aspirations of peoples cannot be appropriated, manipulated, or subordinated to the interests of powerful states.
Ultimately, the legitimacy of international governance must not be measured by the agreements reached among the world’s most powerful governments, but by its capacity to protect and advance the rights, dignity, freedom, and collective aspirations of humanity.
The security of states cannot substitute for the security of peoples.
The sovereignty of governments cannot supersede the self-determination of peoples.
Peace cannot mean impunity.
And multipolarity cannot be mistaken for liberation.
The future of human rights requires a fundamental break with state-centered and imperial conceptions of international governance. It requires a new framework grounded in the collective rights, historical experiences, struggles, and emancipatory aspirations of the peoples of the world.
That is the promise and political necessity of People(s)-Centered Human Rights.
North-South Project for People(s)-Centered Human Rights (PCHR)
November 19, 2026